Part 3: Meaningful Decisions

A good game is a series of interesting decisions.

SID MEIER (APOCRYPHAL)

Have you ever played a game and felt that instead of you playing the game, the game was playing you? This is actually quite common, but many players have trouble narrowing down the root cause of their frustration. They just say the game is “boring,” which is not really much help to a designer who is looking for feedback and analysis. What players are really saying is that the game doesn’t have anything interesting to do. Making decisions is what the players do in a game.

Consider the game LCR. As of June 2019, it has a score of 1, which is the lowest possible rating, in 354 of its 913 reviews on BoardGameGeek, a site that allows players to ...

Get Players Making Decisions, 2nd Edition now with O’Reilly online learning.

O’Reilly members experience live online training, plus books, videos, and digital content from 200+ publishers.