Skip to Main Content
Think Complexity
book

Think Complexity

by Allen B. Downey
March 2012
Beginner content levelBeginner
160 pages
4h 6m
English
O'Reilly Media, Inc.
Content preview from Think Complexity

Chapter 14. Case Study: The Volunteer’s Dilemma

Molly Grossman, Mandy Korpusik, and Philip Loh

The Prairie Dog’s Dilemma

Suppose you are a prairie dog assigned to guard duty with other prairie dogs from your town. When you see a predator coming, you have two choices: sound the alarm or remain silent. If you sound the alarm, you help ensure the safety of the other prairie dogs, but you also encourage the predator to come after you. For you, it is safer to remain silent, but if all guards remain silent, everyone is less safe, including you. What should you do when you see a predator?

This scenario is an example of the Volunteer’s Dilemma, a game similar to the Prisoner’s Dilemma discussed in Prisoner’s Dilemma. In the Prisoner’s Dilemma, each player has two options: cooperate and defect. In the Volunteer’s Dilemma, each player also has two options: volunteer (sound the alarm in our prairie dog example) or ignore (remain silent). If one player volunteers, then the other player is better off ignoring. But if both players ignore, both pay a high cost.

In the Prisoner’s Dilemma, both players are better off if they both cooperate; however, since neither knows what the other will do, each independently comes to the conclusion that he or she should defect.

In the Volunteer’s Dilemma, it is not immediately clear what outcome is best for both players. Suppose the players are named Alice and Bob. If Alice volunteers, Bob is better off ignoring; if Alice ignores, Bob is better off volunteering. This ...

Become an O’Reilly member and get unlimited access to this title plus top books and audiobooks from O’Reilly and nearly 200 top publishers, thousands of courses curated by job role, 150+ live events each month,
and much more.
Start your free trial

You might also like

Unikernels

Unikernels

Russell Pavlicek
Elemental Design Patterns

Elemental Design Patterns

Jason McColm Smith
LEGO® with Dad

LEGO® with Dad

Warren Nash

Publisher Resources

ISBN: 9781449331672Errata