CHAPTER ELEVENThe Procrustean Problem
PART 1: THE CONCEPT AND WHY IT MATTERS
There is an old Greek myth about a man named Procrustes who kept a house by the side of the road. He offered hospitality to travelers. He had one bed. If the traveler was too short for the bed, he stretched them. If the traveler was too tall, he cut them down to size. The bed never changed. The travelers did.
This is a structural risk in coaching.
Usually, it is not intentional or malicious. It is built into the logic of method loyalty. The coach has a model: a way of working, a set of questions, a theory of change. The client arrives with a particular history, nervous system, context, and way of making meaning. Then, without anyone naming it, the client is expected to fit the model. “Procrustean” has become shorthand for this exact error: forcing complex realities into a preset frame rather than updating the frame to match what is real.
When it fits, the method gets the credit. When it does not, the client gets the blame.
If you work with people long enough, that pattern starts to feel unacceptable. This is a problem coaching needs to name more clearly. Psychotherapy researchers were troubled by the same problem decades ago, and their findings help illuminate why it still matters in coaching now.
If that risk is going to be useful in practice, it needs a language for recognizing where mismatch is actually occurring.
CMI TRANSLATION: WHAT “MISMATCH” LOOKS LIKE IN THIS MODEL
In Cognitive Meaning Integration ...
Become an O’Reilly member and get unlimited access to this title plus top books and audiobooks from O’Reilly and nearly 200 top publishers, thousands of courses curated by job role, 150+ live events each month,
and much more.
Read now
Unlock full access