Chapter 11. Comparing Models with Resampling

Once we create two or more models, the next step is to compare them to understand which one is best. In some cases, comparisons might be within-model, where the same model might be evaluated with different features or preprocessing methods. Alternatively, between-model comparisons, such as when we compared linear regression and random forest models in Chapter 10, are the more common scenario.

In either case, the result is a collection of resampled summary statistics (e.g., RMSE, accuracy, etc.) for each model. In this chapter, we’ll first demonstrate how workflow sets can be used to fit multiple models. Then, we’ll discuss important aspects of resampling statistics. Finally, we’ll look at how to formally compare models (using either hypothesis testing or a Bayesian approach).

Creating Multiple Models with Workflow Sets

In Chapter 7 we described the idea of a workflow set where different preprocessors and/or models can be combinatorially generated. In Chapter 10, we used a recipe for the Ames data that included an interaction term as well as spline functions for longitude and latitude. To demonstrate more with workflow sets, let’s create three different linear models that add these preprocessing steps incrementally; we can test whether these additional terms improve the model results. We’ll create three recipes then combine them into a workflow set:


basic_rec <-
  recipe(Sale_Price ...

Get Tidy Modeling with R now with the O’Reilly learning platform.

O’Reilly members experience live online training, plus books, videos, and digital content from nearly 200 publishers.