352 Nonlinear Optimal Control Theory
Then
V (t + δ
k
, x + δ
k
h) − V (t, x) = {V (t + δ
k
, x + δ
k
h) − V (t
k
+ δ
k
, x
k
+ δ
k
h)}
+ {V (t
k
+ δ
k
, x
k
+ δ
k
h) − V (t
k
, x
k
)} + {V (t
k
, x
k
) − V (t, x)}
≡ A
k
+ B
k
+ C
k
From the Lipschitz continuity of V and (12.5.5) we have that
(A
k
+ C
k
) = O(|t − t
k
|) + O(|x −x
k
|) = O(δ
2
k
)
Hence
lim
k→∞
(A
k
+ C
k
)δ
−1
k
= 0. (12.5.6)
Since V is differentiable at (t
k
, x
k
),
B
k
= [V
t
(t
k
, x
k
) + hV
x
(t
k
, x
k
), hi]δ
k
+ o(δ
k
(1 + h))
≥ [V
t
(t
k
, x
k
) + inf
h∈Q(t,x)
hV
x
(t
k
, x
k
), hi]δ
k
+ o(δ
k
).
Hence
B
k
≥ −[−V
t
(t
k
, x
k
) + sup
h∈Q(t,x)
h−V
x
(t
k
, x
k
), hi]δ
k
+ o(δ
k
).
At points of differentiability a viscosity solution satisfies (12.5.1) in the ordi-
nary sense. Hence
lim inf
k→∞
B
k
δ
−1
k
≥ 0. (12.5.7)
From (12 .5.4), (12.5.6), and (12.5.7) we get that
D
−
V (t, x; 1, h) = lim
k→∞
(A
k
+ B
k
+ C
k
)