Problem 4

The Chevalier de Méré Problem II: The Problem of Points (1654)

Problem Two players A and B play a fair game such that the player who wins a total of 6 rounds first wins a prize. Suppose the game unexpectedly stops when A has won a total of 5 rounds and B has won a total of 3 rounds. How should the prize be divided between A and B?

Solution. The division of the prize is determined by the relative probabilities of A and B winning the prize, had they continued the game. Player A is one round short, and player B three rounds short, of winning the prize. The maximum number of hypothetical remaining rounds is (1 + 3) − 1 = 3, each of which could be equally won by A or B. The sample space for the game is Ω = {A1, B1A2, B1B2A3, B1B2B3}. Here B1A2, for example, denotes the event that B would win the first remaining round and A would win the second (and then the game would have to stop since A is only one round short). However, the four sample points in Ω are not equally likely. Event A1 occurs if any one of the following four equally likely events occurs: A1A2A3, A1A2B3, A1B2A3, and A1B2B3. Event B1A2 occurs if any one of the following two equally likely events occurs: B1A2A3 and B1A2B3. In terms of equally likely sample points, the sample space is thus

There are in all eight equally likely outcomes, only one of which (B1B2B3) results in B hypothetically winning the game. Player ...

Get Classic Problems of Probability now with the O’Reilly learning platform.

O’Reilly members experience books, live events, courses curated by job role, and more from O’Reilly and nearly 200 top publishers.