Problem 26

Fisher and the Lady Tasting Tea (1935)

Problem. At a tea party, a lady claims she can discriminate by tasting a cup of tea whether the milk (M) or the tea (T) was poured first. To verify her claim, a statistician presents her in random order with eight cups of tea, and tells her there are four of each type M and T. The lady correctly identifies the four M types (and thus also correctly identifies the four T types). How can the statistician verify if her claim is true?

Solution. Consider Table 26.1, which shows the lady's response in the tea-tasting experiment.

Table 26.1 The Lady's Response in Fisher's Tea-Tasting Experiment.

Conditional on the true states T and M, suppose the lady responds T with probabilities and , respectively. The lady's claim is false if , that is, the odds ratio . Under the null hypothesis , the probability of correctly answering T for each of the four ...

Get Classic Problems of Probability now with the O’Reilly learning platform.

O’Reilly members experience books, live events, courses curated by job role, and more from O’Reilly and nearly 200 top publishers.